TCP and ATM in Wide Area Networks

Benjamin J. Ewy, Joseph B. Evans, Victor S. Frost, Gary J. Minden

Gigabit Network Workshop '94

1994 MAGIC Technical Symposium

1994 Gigabit Testbed Maxijam

This document describes performance measurements taken in the MAGIC gigabit testbed relating to the performance of TCP in wide area ATM networks. In particular, the behavior of TCP with and without ATM cell level pacing is studied. DEC OTTO interfaces, which support ATM/SONET at 155 Mb/s link rates were used as the basis for these studies. These interfaces support cell level flow control as well as schedule-based cell pacing.

Some of the conclusions that might be drawn are: (1) traffic shaping (for example, the OTTO scheduling) is critical when bottlenecks such as OC-3c to TAXI rate mismatches occur in the network, even when only single hosts are involved, (2) traffic shaping substantially improves performance when traffic from multiple hosts is multiplexed across a single link; significant packet losses were observed even with relatively slow sources with no pacing, while cell pacing lead to no observed losses and higher throughput, (3) cell level pacing is necessary because the TCP rate control mechanism does not control traffic burstiness sufficiently to avoid congestion-induced cell losses in wide area networks, primarily due to large TCP segment sizes and small switch buffers.

Abstract: Text, PostScript, PDF
GBN '94 Talk Overheads: PostScript, PDF
Paper: PostScript, PDF

Send comments or questions to Joseph B. Evans,